Room TemperatureFriday
It Doesn’t Have to Look Like the Picture
A letter for anyone facing their first gluten-free holiday season, and my blessing to let it be a little crumbly.
When I first cut gluten, I was not very good at it.
I’d go a few weeks doing everything right, and then a weeknight would roll around where I was tired and hungry and there was a frozen pizza sitting in the freezer. It’s just one pizza, I’d tell myself. Another time it was a hot dog, bun and all. Surely one little hot dog couldn’t hurt. (It could, and it did, and I paid for it the next day.)
I made those small compromises over and over until, one day, I realized I didn’t want to make them anymore. That took a while. Longer than I’d like to admit, honestly.
I’m telling you this because Thanksgiving is a week from today, and somewhere out there someone is heading into their very first holiday season without gluten. Maybe it’s you. If it is, hello! Please keep reading.
I know how overwhelming the beginning feels. When you don’t know where to start, everything gets a bit humdrum, food most of all. But I promise it evens out. The longer you eat this way and live this way, the more it settles in. It just takes a little time and a little practice.
Here’s the thing I want you to hear before anything else. It doesn’t have to look like the picture.
You know the picture I mean, the perfect golden pie. It’s a picture I’m sure you’ve been thinking about all year. Maybe this is the first year you’re hosting. Maybe it’s just you and your loved ones at home, and you aren’t going anywhere. This year, your table might come out a little lumpier than the one in your head. A few things on it might look a bit sad. Let them! Year one is for figuring things out, and hardly anyone is good at it yet. I certainly wasn’t. (See above, re: the hot dog.)
From the Recipe BoxGluten-Free Apple Pie CrumbleSee the Recipe →
I can already hear the list running through your head. The turkey is fine, that one’s easy. But what about the pie? The stuffing? The rolls? Am I just putting out a salad this year? Is a salad really all I can eat now?
If that question is giving you a little knot in your stomach, that’s completely normal. My answer is simpler than it sounds. Make what you can eat. Put out the things you’re comfortable with and the things your body is happy with right now. This is an adjustment, and adjustments are allowed to be a bit plain.
I’ll admit that when I started writing this, I had a small table in mind, someone cooking for one, or for two. Then I thought about the big families, the ones with a few kids running around and a grandparent living at home with them, where Thanksgiving means ten people around the table. Feeding that crowd is a project in any year. Feeding it the year one of you goes gluten-free sounds like a lot, and I’d bet some family is having that exact conversation in their kitchen tonight.
To that family, and to everyone else, do what you can. Your casserole doesn’t have to be perfect. It might look a little different from last year’s. It might not even be pretty! The cake might crumble when you cut into it. Fine, fine and fine. It gets better. You stay the course, you keep trying new things, and every year you know a little more than you did the year before.
From the Recipe BoxSmall-Batch Burnt Basque CheesecakeSee the Recipe →
The one real tip I have is to give yourself a head start. If you’re planning a breakfast casserole for Christmas morning, make it once a couple of days ahead, just to see how it turns out. Gluten-free recipes can surprise you, especially ones that are brand new to you, and Christmas morning is not the moment to find out. Thanksgiving is a week away, which is plenty of time for a test bake or two. Try something this weekend. If you love it, it goes on the table. If you don’t, at least you found out on a regular Saturday and not on Thanksgiving morning.
Our recipes are a good place to start looking. I’ll be upfront, we don’t have a huge collection of pies and casseroles yet. But we do have a few things that work beautifully this time of year. We recently made a pumpkin pie, and a whole batch of festive holiday cookies is coming out over the next couple of weeks, so keep an eye out for those. Every one of them would be right at home on a holiday table. And if what you need isn’t on our site, go have a look around. Plenty of other gluten-free bakers are sharing good recipes, and one of them might have exactly the casserole you’re after.
If it all starts to feel like too much, keep it very simple. Our chocolate orange spoon cake is made in a microwave-safe bowl. You spoon it out, and that’s dessert. For Thanksgiving, for Christmas, for New Year’s. Done!
Here’s what I’d actually do, though. Put your effort into the places where gluten-free doesn’t come into it at all. The table, for one. Get the nice plates out. Throw some decorations down, light a candle, fold the napkins into something ridiculous. When the room looks wonderful, people care a lot less about how the stuffing compares to the one they grew up with. It solves about half the problem, and it happens to be the fun half.
From the Recipe BoxBrazilian Cheese Bread (Pão de Queijo)See the Recipe →
So this year might not turn out the way you imagined it back in January. That’s okay. Be patient with yourself. You’re doing this for your health, and you’re doing it so you can be a better version of yourself, not just to keep up with tradition.
And please, learn from me and my hot dog. When the familiar pie is sitting right there, full of gluten, and you know exactly how you’ll feel tomorrow, maybe skip it this time. Make the imperfect one instead, and have fun doing it.
One More Thing!
What’s going on your imperfect table this year? A crumbly cake, a lopsided pie, a casserole that came out a little beige?
Write to me and tell me about it. I’ll be cheering you on from here.
Thanks for reading, and see you next Friday.
Write to me at hello@brimly.co. Past issues are archived here.
Stephnie Grace is a recipe developer, editor, and co-founder of Brimly, specializing in gluten-free, soy-free, and gum-free baking. She writes Room Temperature, a Friday letter from behind the scenes at Brimly, for anyone who is new to gluten-free and not sure where to start.







